Never cast
It exists on a sign in the artwork and nowhere else

Scream’s Stab Movies
EASTER EGG

This is going to hurt.
Stab: The Musical has never appeared in a Scream film. It turned up in the promotional artwork for Scream 6, on a sign, alongside Wrongly Accused: The Musical, which is the stage version of Gale Weathers’ book about Cotton Weary. It is an Easter egg rather than anything the films have confirmed.
Stab: The Musical is a stage musical based on the Stab films. It exists only on billboards in a piece of Scream VI promotional art. No story, songs or cast have ever been given for it, and it never comes up in the film.
It first turned up in February 2023 on a limited-edition collector's print by the artist Doaly. Paramount gave the print to fans who bought tickets to the Scream VI Fan Event Screening, a 3D showing at 5 p.m. on Thursday, March 9, 2023, the night before the film opened. The official Scream Movies account announced it on Twitter, and prints went out while supplies lasted.
The print shows a giant Ghost Face mask and a gloved hand holding a knife over Times Square at night, with a crowd of people and Ghost Faces in the street below. Fangirlish called it a game of spot the Ghost Face. The title SCREAM VI runs down the side of a building. The billboards are all made up for the Scream world: Every Day Good Morning with Gale Weathers, Blackmore University, "New York. New Rules.", a sign saying the NYC Halloween Parade is 5 days away, and news tickers about the McKenzie family found murdered in a series of stabbings in the city.
Stab: The Musical gets two of those billboards, one high on a tower and one down at street level. Both carry the line "This is going to hurt" over a big STAB logo with THE MUSICAL underneath. The top one has green STAB lettering on a dark board. The street-level one has white STAB lettering on a green board, with a Ghost Face mask beside it.
Scream VI moved the story to New York, so a Stab show on Broadway fits that world. Fangirlish made the same point, tying the idea back to Sidney's play at Windsor College in Scream 2. Real murders became Gale Weathers' books, the books became the Stab movies, and here the movies have become a stage show.
StabMovies.com reports that another title, Wrongly Accused: The Musical, showed up first on other Scream VI promo art. It would be based on Gale Weathers' first book, Wrongly Accused: The Maureen Prescott Murder, about Cotton Weary's wrongful conviction. No other source checked confirms that artwork, and it is not on the Doaly print.
Source boundary: Poster Posse identifies the image as official Scream VI digital marketing for Paramount Studios and names Doaly as artist. Paramount's fan-event announcement, quoted by Bloody Disgusting, identifies the giveaway as a limited-edition collector's print for the March 9, 2023 screening. Those sources verify the campaign art and giveaway; they do not announce a real musical production.
It exists on a sign in the artwork and nowhere else
Artist of the Scream VI Fan Event Screening print that shows the Stab: The Musical billboards
Two Stab: The Musical billboards on Doaly's Times Square print for the Scream VI Fan Event Screening, 2023. Each reads "This is going to hurt" above a STAB logo and THE MUSICAL. The print's fine print reads 2023 Par. Pics., with the Ghost Face trademark credited to Fun World Div., Easter Unlimited, Inc.
Stab: The Musical appears only on the billboards in official Scream VI campaign artwork. No songs, composer, lyricist, cast recording or stage production have been identified; there is no released film, recorded show, streaming, digital, cast-album or physical-media edition. The limited-edition Doaly print is the collectible.